The Colour Pop Lippie Pencils are known to be creamy and non-tugging on the lips. They also have great wearing time. At $5 a POP you can't beat the quality.
The first up is "KAE" which was introduced in the Colour Pop/Karrueche Collaboration. It's listed as
-A deep warm yellow brown.
Next, "Pitch" which is listed as a -Rich blackened chocolate brown.
Third, is "Creature" listed as- A deepened blackened burgundy red in a matte finish.
Lastly, is "Rooch" which was also part of the ColourPop/Karrueche Collaboration. It's listed as-
A deepened Russet Wine.